2025 – Texas Overhands (Brendan T)
2024 – Albino Cedar Mice (Sam N)
2023 – Big Willies (Steve S)
2022* ~ Team ouija00 (David W) & Texas Overhands (Brendan T) Co-champions due to unique circumstances
2021 ~ Team sportykid (Rob K)
2020 ~ COVID – No Season
2019 ~ Balls Deep (Matt S)
2018 ~ Cooked on a Thielen (Mike G)
2017 ~ LictaLottaPuss (Bob D)
2016 ~ Shaved Beavers (Ryan S)
2015 ~ Shaved Beavers (Ryan S)
2014 ~ Multiple Scorgasims (Brian M)
2013 ~ Multiple Scorgasims (Brian M)
2012 ~ Multiple Scorgasims (Brian M)
2011 ~ Red Snappers (Greg K)
2010 ~ Big Willies (Steve S)
2009 ~ Shaved Beavers (Ryan S)
2008 ~ I.R.J.B. (James Strong)
2007 ~ Shaved Beavers (Ryan S)
2006 ~ I.R.J.B. (James S)
2005 ~ Fighting Cocks (Tom S)
2001 ~ 2004 History is lost